The main differences
| Topic | Original Medicare (with or without Medigap) | Medicare Advantage |
|---|---|---|
| Who pays | Medicare pays providers directly | A private company approved by Medicare |
| Doctors | Any provider in the U.S. who accepts Medicare | Usually the plan's network (HMO or PPO) |
| Referrals and approvals | No referral needed to see a specialist | Many plans require referrals or prior authorization |
| Yearly spending limit | None; Medigap helps pay what Medicare doesn't | Yes; in 2027 no plan may set an in-network limit above $9,850 |
| Drugs | Separate Part D plan (or SeniorCare at 65+) | Usually included |
| Travel in the U.S. | Works nationwide | Emergencies nationwide; other care depends on the plan |
What's different in Wisconsin
- Medigap has no lettered plans. Wisconsin uses a basic policy with state-mandated benefits plus optional riders you choose. See Why are Wisconsin Medigap plans different?
- No birthday rule. Outside your Medigap open enrollment (6 months from the start of Part B) and guaranteed-issue situations, a company can ask about your health. See Does Wisconsin have a birthday rule?
- Medicare Advantage choices vary by county. For 2027, CMS lists 33 plans open to everyone in Milwaukee County, 29 in Dane and 5 in Bayfield. See plans by county.
- OCI doesn't regulate Medicare Advantage, so those plans don't have to cover Wisconsin's mandated benefits and aren't guaranteed renewable (OCI guide PI-002). Some counties also have Medicare Cost plans, a third option.
Medicare Advantage plans may offer extra benefits not covered by Original Medicare, such as dental, vision or hearing. Extra benefits vary by plan and county, may have limits and costs, and not every plan offers them. Check a plan's Summary of Benefits or Evidence of Coverage.
If you winter elsewhere
Original Medicare works in every state and Puerto Rico. A Medicare Advantage plan must disenroll you if you're out of its area more than 6 months in a row, unless it has a visitor program (42 CFR 422.74). Outside the U.S., Medicare rarely pays; Wisconsin's foreign travel emergency rider can help. See snowbirds and wintering out of state.
How to decide
- List your doctors, hospital, pharmacy and prescriptions.
- Ask your doctors whether they accept Medicare and which plan networks they're in.
- Compare both paths: a Medicare Advantage plan in your county against Original Medicare with Medigap and Part D.
- Decide during your enrollment period and keep your coverage letters.
To compare plans from the companies they work with, you can request a call from a licensed insurance agent. Overview: Medicare Advantage in Wisconsin and Wisconsin Medigap vs. Medicare Advantage; also HMO vs. PPO.
Sources
- Medicare.gov — Your health plan options
- Medicare.gov — Medigap (Medicare Supplement Insurance)
- Wisconsin OCI — Guide to Health Insurance for People with Medicare, PI-002 (R 04/2026)
- CMS — CY2027 Landscape file and CY2027 Part C out-of-pocket limits
- eCFR — 42 CFR 422.74
More questions in this guide
- What is the difference between an HMO and a PPO Medicare Advantage plan in Wisconsin?
- How does Medicare Advantage work in Wisconsin?
- How many Medicare Advantage plans are in my Wisconsin county for 2027?
- Is my Medicare Advantage plan ending in 2027 in Wisconsin?
- Are there Medicare Cost plans in Wisconsin?
- Can I switch from Medicare Advantage back to Original Medicare in Wisconsin?
Part of the guide: Medicare Advantage in Wisconsin · All questions
Frequently asked questions
Which one is better?
It depends on your doctors, your drugs, how much you travel and what you can afford. Neither is best for everyone. Compare both against your list of doctors and prescriptions before you decide.
Can I have Medicare Advantage and Medigap at the same time?
It doesn't work: Medigap doesn't pay a Medicare Advantage plan's costs, and it's illegal to sell you Medigap while you have Medicare Advantage unless you're switching back to Original Medicare.
If I choose Medicare Advantage, can I change later?
Yes, during enrollment periods. But in Wisconsin, buying Medigap later can mean health questions unless you have a guaranteed right, such as the 12-month trial right.
Medicare in your Wisconsin county
Plans, licensed agents and help, county by county: Milwaukee · Dane · Waukesha · Brown · Racine · Outagamie · Winnebago · Kenosha · Rock · Marathon · Washington · La Crosse · Sheboygan · Eau Claire · Walworth · Fond du Lac · St. Croix · Ozaukee · Dodge · Jefferson · All 72 counties →