What we checked
| Source | What it says |
|---|---|
| Wis. Adm. Code Ins 3.39 (Medicare supplement rule) | No birthday, anniversary or annual switch right |
| Wis. Stat. ch. 632 (through 2025 Wis. Act 247) | No birthday or anniversary provision |
| OCI guide PI-002 (R 04/2026) | Describes open enrollment as a one-time-only six-month period |
| 2023 AB 404 and SB 412 | Would have created a 30-day window starting on your birthday to switch to equal or lesser benefits; both failed to pass on April 15, 2024 |
Earlier bills (2017 AB 1022, 2021 SB 1021 and AB 1086) weren't enacted either.
When you can buy or switch without health questions
- Open enrollment: the 6 months starting with your first month of Part B, at any age, plus a second 6 months at 65 if you first enrolled in Part B under 65 (Ins 3.39 (3r)). See Medigap open enrollment in Wisconsin.
- Guaranteed issue: federal situations (your Medicare Advantage plan ends, a 12-month trial right, your insurer goes bankrupt) plus Wisconsin's own: your employer plan's cost to you rises more than 25% in a year and above the Medigap premium; an employer plan primary to Medicare ends; you dropped employer coverage for Medicare Advantage and left within 12 months; a Select network hospital leaves; or you lose Medicaid. You generally have 63 days (Ins 3.39 (34)).
- Medicare Select to standard: after a Select policy has been in force 6 months, the company must let you move to its non-network policy with comparable or lesser benefits without health questions (Ins 3.39 (30t)). See Medicare Select in Wisconsin.
Otherwise: what to expect
Outside those windows, a company can review your health and decline you or charge more. If you're approved, you have 30 days to return the new policy for a refund (Wis. Stat. 632.73 (2m)), so keep your old policy until the new one is in force. A preexisting-condition wait can't exceed 6 months, and time on your old policy counts toward it (Wis. Stat. 632.76 (2)(b); Ins 3.39 (27)). You can also add a rider to your current policy at any time, subject to health questions.
People moving here from a state with a birthday rule, such as Nevada or Oregon, lose that right once they live in Wisconsin; their current policy stays guaranteed renewable. See Can I keep my Medigap if I move? and moving to Wisconsin with Medicare.
To compare policies from the companies they work with, you can request a call from a licensed insurance agent. Overview: Medigap in Wisconsin; also why Wisconsin Medigap is different.
Sources
- Wis. Adm. Code Ins 3.39 (3r), (27), (30t), (34)
- Wis. Stat. ch. 632 (2023-24, updated through 2025 Wis. Act 247)
- Wisconsin Legislature — 2023 Assembly Bill 404
- Wisconsin Legislature — 2023 Senate Bill 412
- Wisconsin OCI — Guide to Health Insurance for People with Medicare, PI-002 (R 04/2026)
More questions in this guide
- Can I keep my Wisconsin Medigap policy if I move to another state?
- What is a Medicare SELECT policy in Wisconsin?
- When can I buy a Medigap policy in Wisconsin without health questions?
- Can I get a Medicare supplement under 65 on disability in Wisconsin?
- What is a Medicare supplement (Medigap) and how does it work in Wisconsin?
- Why are Wisconsin Medigap plans different from Plan G and Plan N?
- What does the Wisconsin Medigap basic plan cover, and what riders can I add?
- What are the 50% and 25% cost-sharing Medigap policies in Wisconsin?
Part of the guide: Medigap (Medicare Supplement) in Wisconsin · All questions
Frequently asked questions
Can I switch Medigap plans in Wisconsin without answering health questions?
Only in certain situations: your 6-month open enrollment, a guaranteed-issue event such as losing employer coverage or your Medicare Advantage plan ending, or after 6 months in a Medicare Select policy when moving to the same company's standard policy. Otherwise the new company can ask about your health.
If I switch with health questions, does a new waiting period start?
If your current policy has been in force at least 6 months, the new company must credit the waiting periods you've already satisfied (Ins 3.39 (27)).
Could Wisconsin pass a birthday rule later?
Possibly. Bills have been introduced in several sessions but none has passed. We'll update this page if the law changes.
Medicare in your Wisconsin county
Plans, licensed agents and help, county by county: Milwaukee · Dane · Waukesha · Brown · Racine · Outagamie · Winnebago · Kenosha · Rock · Marathon · Washington · La Crosse · Sheboygan · Eau Claire · Walworth · Fond du Lac · St. Croix · Ozaukee · Dodge · Jefferson · All 72 counties →