2027 alertSecurity Health Plan, UnitedHealthcare, Aspirus Health Plan and 2 other companies end some Medicare Advantage plans in Wisconsin on December 31. (CMS data) 15 days left in Annual Enrollment (ends Dec. 7).Is your plan ending? →
Appeals

Medicare appeals in Wisconsin

If Original Medicare, a Medicare Advantage plan or a Part D plan in Wisconsin denies a service, drug or payment, you can appeal through up to five federal levels, starting by the deadline on your notice. If a hospital stay or other covered care is ending too soon, call Wisconsin's Medicare quality improvement organization, Commence Health (formerly Livanta), at 1-888-524-9900.

Quick answers

How long do I have to appeal?
Original Medicare: 120 days from the date you get your Medicare Summary Notice. Medicare Advantage or Part D: 65 days from the date on the plan's denial notice. Later levels are generally 60 days, except 180 days for the second Original Medicare level.
Who handles hospital discharge appeals in Wisconsin?
The Beneficiary and Family Centered Care Quality Improvement Organization (BFCC-QIO) for Region 5, Commence Health, formerly called Livanta. Its helpline is 1-888-524-9900. Call no later than your planned discharge day.
How fast must a Medicare Advantage plan decide on prior authorization?
Since January 1, 2026, a plan must decide a standard prior authorization request within 7 calendar days and an expedited one within 72 hours (42 CFR 422.568 and 422.572).
How do I file a complaint against an insurance agent in Wisconsin?
With the Office of the Commissioner of Insurance (OCI): call 1-800-236-8517 or 608-266-3585, or use its online complaint form. OCI also takes complaints about Medicare supplement insurers. A complaint doesn't replace a Medicare appeal.
Are Medicare appeals different in Wisconsin than in other states?
The appeal levels are federal and the same everywhere. What's Wisconsin-specific is who you call: Commence Health for fast appeals, OCI for Medigap and agent complaints, and Wisconsin Medicaid for Medicaid decisions.
Who can help me with the appeal process?
Call 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227, TTY 1-877-486-2048). Your doctor can support your appeal, and you can name a family member as your representative with form CMS-1696.

Start with your notice

Every Medicare denial comes in writing and says how to appeal and by when. Which notice you get depends on your coverage:

  • Original Medicare: the Medicare Summary Notice (MSN), mailed every four months if you had services, or sooner in your Medicare.gov account.
  • Medicare Advantage: a written denial notice from the plan, and an Explanation of Benefits for payment decisions. In July 2026, 789,533 of Wisconsin's 1,376,185 people with Medicare were in Medicare Advantage or another Medicare health plan, so for many Wisconsinites the plan makes the first decision.
  • Part D: a notice from your drug plan. If a pharmacy can't fill a prescription, ask how to contact the plan for a coverage decision.

Keep copies of everything and ask your doctor for a letter explaining why you need the service or drug. To let a family member act for you, use Medicare's Appointment of Representative form (CMS-1696); see caregivers and Medicare. Step by step: how do I appeal a Medicare denial in Wisconsin?

The five levels in Original Medicare

LevelWho decidesDeadline to ask
1. RedeterminationThe Medicare Administrative Contractor that processed the claim (address on your MSN)120 days from the date you get the MSN; decision generally within 60 days
2. ReconsiderationA Qualified Independent Contractor (QIC)180 days after the level 1 decision; decision within 60 days
3. HearingOffice of Medicare Hearings and Appeals (an Administrative Law Judge, or a review of the record)60 days after the level 2 decision
4. Appeals Council reviewMedicare Appeals Council60 days after the level 3 decision
5. Judicial reviewFederal district court60 days after the Appeals Council decision

Levels 3 and 5 apply only if the amount in dispute reaches a minimum Medicare sets each year; the level 5 minimum is much higher, and you may be able to combine claims to reach it. Medicare.gov lists the current amounts. Hearings are usually by phone or video, so you don't need to travel from Superior or Rhinelander to take part.

If you have a Wisconsin Medicare supplement policy, it pays its share only after Medicare approves the claim, so a successful Medicare appeal also brings in the supplement's payment.

Medicare Advantage appeals

  1. Organization determination. The plan decides whether to cover a service or pay a claim, including prior authorization. Since January 1, 2026, a standard prior authorization decision is due within 7 calendar days; other standard service requests within 14. If waiting could seriously harm your health, ask for a fast decision (72 hours).
  2. Reconsideration (level 1). Appeal within 65 days of the date on the denial notice. The plan decides within 30 days for a service you haven't received, 60 days for a payment, 7 days for a Part B drug, or 72 hours for a fast appeal. It can take up to 14 more days in some cases and must tell you in writing.
  3. Independent Review Entity (level 2). If the plan keeps its denial, it must send your case to an independent reviewer automatically.
  4. Levels 3 to 5. A hearing, the Medicare Appeals Council and federal court, with the same yearly minimum amounts.

Have a Medicare Cost plan? Follow the appeal instructions on whatever notice you get. Care you got outside a Cost plan's network is paid by Original Medicare, so a denial of that care comes on an MSN.

Part D drug appeals and exceptions

  1. Coverage determination or exception. Ask the plan to cover a drug, including an exception to its drug list, a step-therapy or quantity rule, or a cost tier. Your prescriber's statement of the medical reason is required for an exception.
  2. Redetermination (level 1). Within 65 days of the denial notice. The plan decides within 7 days (14 for a payment request), or 72 hours if fast.
  3. Independent Review Entity (level 2). Unlike Medicare Advantage medical appeals, you must ask for this yourself, within 60 days of the plan's decision.
  4. Levels 3 to 5. As above.

If cost is the problem, not a denial: Part D has a yearly out-of-pocket cap ($2,400 in 2027), and you may qualify for Extra Help, a Medicare Savings Program or SeniorCare, Wisconsin's own drug program for residents 65 and older. See Extra Help, Medicare Savings Programs and SeniorCare.

When a hospital stay or other care ends too soon

A separate, faster process applies when covered care is ending. In Wisconsin, these appeals go to Commence Health, the BFCC-QIO for CMS's Region 5 (Illinois, Indiana, Michigan, Minnesota, Ohio and Wisconsin). Commence Health was called Livanta until 2025, and some notices may still print the old name; the helpline is 1-888-524-9900. The process is the same with Original Medicare and with Medicare Advantage.

Leaving the hospital

You get An Important Message from Medicare within 2 days of admission and again before discharge if the first came more than 2 days earlier. Call no later than your planned discharge day. The QIO decides within one day of getting the information it needs, and if you asked on time you can stay without paying for those days, other than usual deductibles or coinsurance.

Skilled nursing, home health, hospice

You get a Notice of Medicare Non-Coverage at least 2 days before covered services end at a skilled nursing facility, from a home health agency or hospice, or at a comprehensive outpatient rehabilitation facility. Call by noon of the day before the end date on the notice.

The QIO also takes complaints about the quality of care you got under Medicare. Step by step: how do I appeal a hospital discharge in Wisconsin?

If you also have Wisconsin Medicaid

Medicare and Medicaid decisions are usually appealed separately. Appeal a Medicare or Medicare Advantage decision with the steps above. For a Medicaid service or eligibility decision, follow the fair hearing instructions on the Wisconsin Medicaid notice; ForwardHealth Member Services is 800-362-3002. One exception: members of the Medicare plans that go with Family Care Partnership have a single, integrated appeals process for Medicare and Medicaid services, described in the plan's member materials. See Wisconsin Medicaid and Medicare and D-SNPs in Wisconsin.

Appealing IRMAA

Social Security, not Medicare, decides whether you pay the income-related monthly adjustment amount on Part B and Part D premiums, using your tax return from two years earlier. IRMAA brackets are cliffs: one dollar over a limit raises the whole amount. If your income dropped after a life-changing event such as retiring, ask Social Security for a new decision with Form SSA-44; if the tax data was wrong, ask for a reconsideration within 60 days. See Medicare costs in 2027.

Complaints that aren't appeals

For problems that aren't coverage decisions, such as long waits or how you were treated, file a grievance with your Medicare Advantage or Part D plan; its Evidence of Coverage says how. You can also report a plan problem to 1-800-MEDICARE.

Wisconsin's Office of the Commissioner of Insurance (OCI) takes complaints about insurance companies and agents, including Medicare supplement insurers and agent misconduct. Call 1-800-236-8517 or 608-266-3585 (TTY 711), or start from its Types of Complaints page. OCI's consumer guide "Denials and Cancellations" (PI-024) covers insurance denials. A complaint to OCI doesn't stop the clock on a Medicare appeal, so file the appeal by its deadline too. Check an agent's license with OCI's license lookup. Suspect billing for care you never got? See Medicare fraud in Wisconsin, reporting scam calls and new-card scam calls.

When an appeal isn't the answer

If a plan keeps denying a drug or service you need, or your doctor leaves its network, changing plans in an enrollment period you qualify for may help. Open Enrollment runs through December 7, 2026, and people whose plan is ending have more time; see plans ending in 2027 and open enrollment in Wisconsin. A licensed insurance agent who works with Benefits Life can explain plans from the companies they work with; you can request a call from a licensed insurance agent. For the appeal itself, follow your notice.

Sources

Every question in this guide

Frequently asked questions

Can my doctor file the appeal for me?

For a Medicare Advantage service you haven't received yet, or a Part D drug, your doctor or prescriber can request the appeal. Anyone else, such as a family member, needs to be named on Medicare's Appointment of Representative form (CMS-1696).

What if I miss the appeal deadline?

Medicare.gov says you can still file and ask for a decision if you show good cause for missing it, such as an illness or accident. Explain why in your request.

Does a Wisconsin Medicare supplement policy pay if Medicare denies a claim?

Generally not. A Medicare supplement policy pays its share after Medicare approves an Original Medicare claim, so appeal to Medicare first.

Can a licensed insurance agent file my appeal?

An agent can't overturn a decision, but if a plan keeps denying care you need, an agent can explain when you can switch plans. You can request a call from a licensed insurance agent.

Licensed insurance agents who can help Wisconsin residents by phone

These independent insurance agents are licensed in Wisconsin and work with Benefits Life, the publisher of this site. When they enroll you in a plan, the agent and Benefits Life may be paid by the insurance company. Learn more.

David Gresl

David Gresl

Accepting new clients

Independent insurance agent licensed in Wisconsin

Las Vegas, NV · English

Wendi Schoonover

Wendi Schoonover

Accepting new clients

Independent insurance agent licensed in Wisconsin

Tulsa, OK

Robin Depies

Robin Depies

Accepting new clients

Independent insurance agent licensed in Wisconsin

Colorado Springs, CO · English

Andrea Ensch

Andrea Ensch

Accepting new clients

Independent insurance agent licensed in Wisconsin

Colorado Springs, CO · English

See all agents licensed in Wisconsin →

Request a call from

Only this agent gets your request. No cost to you.