Start with the notice
Every denial comes in writing and says how to appeal and by when. Original Medicare denials appear on the Medicare Summary Notice (MSN), mailed every four months if you had services and available sooner in your Medicare.gov account. Medicare Advantage and Part D plans send their own notice. In July 2026, 789,533 of Wisconsin's 1,376,185 people with Medicare were in Medicare Advantage, so for most Wisconsinites the first appeal goes to the plan.
How to file the first appeal
- Read why it was denied. A missing prior authorization, a billing code error and a "not medically necessary" finding each need a different answer.
- Get your doctor's support. Ask for a letter or records explaining why you need the service or drug.
- File by the deadline. Original Medicare: a redetermination request, on the form or in a letter, to the contractor whose address is on the MSN. Medicare Advantage: a reconsideration request to the plan. Part D: a redetermination request to the plan.
- Keep copies and note who you spoke with and when.
- Read the decision. If you lose, the letter tells you how to go to the next level.
The five levels
| Level | Original Medicare | Medicare Advantage | Part D |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Redetermination by the claims contractor (120 days) | Reconsideration by the plan (65 days) | Redetermination by the plan (65 days) |
| 2 | Qualified Independent Contractor (180 days) | Independent Review Entity (sent automatically) | Independent Review Entity (you ask, within 60 days) |
| 3 to 5 | Office of Medicare Hearings and Appeals, the Medicare Appeals Council, then federal court, each within 60 days; levels 3 and 5 need a minimum amount in dispute that Medicare sets each year | ||
Missed a deadline? Medicare.gov says you can still ask if you have good cause, such as an illness or accident.
Wisconsin points
- Medigap: a Wisconsin Medigap policy pays after Medicare approves an Original Medicare claim, so appeal to Medicare first. Problems with the Medigap insurer itself go to OCI.
- Medicare and Wisconsin Medicaid: Medicaid decisions follow the fair hearing instructions on the Medicaid notice, through the Division of Hearings and Appeals. Family Care Partnership members in the companion special needs plans use one integrated appeal process for both programs.
- Agent problems: misleading sales go to OCI's complaint form; see Medicare appeals in Wisconsin.
- Questions about the process: 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227, TTY 1-877-486-2048).
Related: appealing a hospital discharge, reporting Medicare scam calls and new-card scam calls. If you're choosing a plan for next year after a denial, you can request a call from a licensed insurance agent.
Sources
- Medicare.gov — Appeals in Original Medicare
- Medicare.gov — Appeals in Medicare health plans
- Medicare.gov — Appeals in Medicare drug plans
- 42 CFR 405.942 — Time frame for filing a redetermination request
- Wisconsin OCI — Types of complaints
- Wisconsin Division of Hearings and Appeals — Requesting a hearing
- Wisconsin DHS — Family Care Partnership dual eligible special needs plan contract (integrated appeals)
More questions in this guide
- How do I appeal a hospital discharge in Wisconsin?
- How do I report Medicare scam calls in Wisconsin?
- Someone called saying they will send me a new Medicare card. Is it a scam?
Part of the guide: Medicare appeals in Wisconsin · All questions
Frequently asked questions
Can Wisconsin's insurance office overturn a Medicare denial?
No. Medicare, Medicare Advantage and Part D decisions go through the federal appeal levels on your notice. The Office of the Commissioner of Insurance (OCI) takes complaints about insurance companies and agents, including Medigap insurers, at 1-800-236-8517 or 608-266-3585.
What if waiting could harm my health?
Ask for a fast (expedited) appeal. A Medicare Advantage or Part D plan must decide within 72 hours if it agrees, or your doctor says, that waiting could seriously jeopardize your health.
Who do I call if a hospital is discharging me?
That's a separate, faster appeal. Call Commence Health (formerly Livanta), the Medicare quality improvement organization for Wisconsin, at 1-888-524-9900, no later than your planned discharge day.
Medicare in your Wisconsin county
Plans, licensed agents and help, county by county: Milwaukee · Dane · Waukesha · Brown · Racine · Outagamie · Winnebago · Kenosha · Rock · Marathon · Washington · La Crosse · Sheboygan · Eau Claire · Walworth · Fond du Lac · St. Croix · Ozaukee · Dodge · Jefferson · All 72 counties →