2027 alertSecurity Health Plan, UnitedHealthcare, Aspirus Health Plan and 2 other companies end some Medicare Advantage plans in Wisconsin on December 31. (CMS data) 15 days left in Annual Enrollment (ends Dec. 7).Is your plan ending? →
Questions

Should I choose SeniorCare or Medicare Part D in Wisconsin?

In Wisconsin you don't have to choose: DHS says you can have SeniorCare and a Medicare Part D plan at the same time, or just one. SeniorCare counts as creditable coverage, so skipping Part D doesn't bring a late penalty. Part D adds a yearly out-of-pocket cap, Extra Help and coverage at pharmacies outside Wisconsin.

SeniorCare and Part D side by side

SeniorCareMedicare Part D
Who can joinWisconsin residents 65+ who are citizens or have a qualifying immigration status; not on full-benefit MedicaidAnyone with Medicare Part A or Part B who lives in the plan's area
Run byWisconsin DHSPrivate plans approved by Medicare
Yearly costsA per-person enrollment fee; a deductible or spenddown at higher income levels; then a copay per prescriptionA monthly premium that varies by plan; a deductible of up to $700 in 2027; 25% coinsurance or copays
Yearly capDHS doesn't describe one; copays continue for the 12-month periodNothing more for covered drugs once you spend $2,400 in 2027
PharmaciesMore than 95% of Wisconsin pharmacies; out of state only in emergencies (U.S., Canada, Mexico) or with prior approvalThe plan's network pharmacies across the U.S.
DrugsMost drugs whose maker signed a state rebate agreement; Levels 2B and 3 only thoseThe plan's formulary
Help with costsYour level is set by incomeExtra Help works only with Part D

Who each tends to fit

SeniorCare alone can make sense if you stay in Wisconsin, take few or low-cost drugs, and your income puts you in Level 1 (at or below 160% of the federal poverty level, with no deductible). It keeps you protected from the Part D late penalty because DHS and OCI both treat it as creditable coverage.

Part D is worth a close look if you spend winters in Arizona, Florida or Texas, take expensive brand-name drugs (the yearly cap), or qualify for Extra Help. SeniorCare's Levels 2B and 3 cover only drugs whose makers signed Wisconsin's rebate agreement, and Level 3 starts with a spenddown at full retail price.

Both can make sense when your Part D plan leaves gaps. CMS's 2026 approval of SeniorCare says that for people with Part D, SeniorCare fills a gap for drugs the other coverage doesn't pay for.

How to decide

  1. Find your SeniorCare level. Compare your expected 12-month income with the SeniorCare income limits.
  2. List your drugs and pharmacies, including any outside Wisconsin.
  3. Price Part D plans. Wisconsin has 8 standalone Part D plans for 2027, plus Medicare Advantage plans with drug coverage. Use Medicare's Plan Finder or PlanMatch; see how to choose a Part D plan.
  4. Check Extra Help. If you might qualify, apply at Social Security first.
  5. Keep SeniorCare until Part D starts. DHS warns that letting SeniorCare end without other drug coverage can mean a penalty later.

More: Do I need Part D if I have SeniorCare? and the guide SeniorCare in Wisconsin.

Sources

More questions in this guide

Part of the guide: SeniorCare: Wisconsin's prescription drug program for people 65 and older · All questions

Frequently asked questions

If I have both, which one pays first?

Part D pays first. DHS calls SeniorCare the payer of last resort: your pharmacy bills Medicare drug coverage, then SeniorCare.

Can I switch from SeniorCare to Part D any time?

You can apply for SeniorCare any month after you turn 65, but you generally join or change Part D plans during Open Enrollment, October 15 to December 7, or when a Special Enrollment Period applies. Stay on SeniorCare until your Part D coverage starts.

Will a licensed insurance agent tell me which one to pick?

An agent can compare Part D plans from the companies they work with against your drugs and pharmacies. SeniorCare is a state program, so questions about your level go to SeniorCare Customer Service at 800-657-2038. You can request a call from a licensed insurance agent.

Licensed insurance agents who can help Wisconsin residents by phone

These independent insurance agents are licensed in Wisconsin and work with Benefits Life, the publisher of this site. When they enroll you in a plan, the agent and Benefits Life may be paid by the insurance company. Learn more.

Robin Depies

Robin Depies

Accepting new clients

Independent insurance agent licensed in Wisconsin

Colorado Springs, CO · English

Andrea Ensch

Andrea Ensch

Accepting new clients

Independent insurance agent licensed in Wisconsin

Colorado Springs, CO · English

David Gresl

David Gresl

Accepting new clients

Independent insurance agent licensed in Wisconsin

Las Vegas, NV · English

Berenice Suarez

Berenice Suarez

Accepting new clients

Independent insurance agent licensed in Wisconsin

Colorado Springs, CO · English, Spanish

See all agents licensed in Wisconsin →

Request a call from

Only this agent gets your request. No cost to you.